認真： 林冠英夫人已經犯戒

110_01

林冠英夫人這樣做已經嚴重犯戒了，怎麽辦？


她的  牧師/神父  沒有告訴她這樣做是不對的嗎？

cikmekyee

今天才知道林冠英是天主教徒！
请问剃光头是犯了十戒的哪一戒？（需要其他的章节来支持）

stocking1985

圣经里那是保罗写给当时哥林多教会信徒的行为准则。

JowY

如果天主教徒认为这个“犯戒”比吴春来之辈的金钱政治还严重的话，我无语了。

110_01

cikmekyee 发表于 16-5-2013 09:14 PM
今天才知道林冠英是天主教徒！
请问剃光头是犯了十戒的哪一戒？（需要其他的章节来支持）

犯了  哥林多前書   的  “女人剃光頭是羞恥”  ，這次我引新約了

cikmekyee

110_01 发表于 17-5-2013 09:46 PM
犯了  哥林多前書   的  “女人剃光頭是羞恥”  ，這次我引新約了

没听过，请给我章节，好让我去查考一下。

110_01

cikmekyee 发表于 17-5-2013 11:37 PM
没听过，请给我章节，好让我去查考一下。

看圖

cikmekyee

110_01 发表于 17-5-2013 11:46 PM
看圖

呵呵，就是那些歧视女性的那些经文啊！我从来不看的，圣经也出现这些歧视女性的东西实在是哀哉！

三楼的stocking1985说的有理，这是一个个案，不能沦为论点，除非你能多举出其他章节来支持这个论点。

110_01

cikmekyee 发表于 17-5-2013 11:57 PM
呵呵，就是那些歧视女性的那些经文啊！我从来不看的，圣经也出现这些歧视女性的东西实在是哀哉！

三楼 ...

《Tanakh》可以找到很多歧視女性的經文支援這一段，女人是上帝用男人肋骨造出來的就證明了這一點

joesoon01

有这样写吗？她的动机是反金钱政治。。。

110_01

joesoon01 发表于 18-5-2013 12:38 AM
有这样写吗？她的动机是反金钱政治。。。

不管動機爲何，根據  《哥林多前書  11：5-6》   婦女剃髮就是一種羞恥

joesoon01

可能他是无心的。。

mylover

那些要开‘脑’手术的基督女性不就等死？

cikmekyee

mylover 发表于 18-5-2013 01:31 AM
那些要开‘脑’手术的基督女性不就等死？

你说的对，给你加分。
我已经说了，那是礼节，礼节只用在历史批判，不能用在另一个时代，它和诫命不同。
做人太极端就是不好。

JowY

110_01 发表于 18-5-2013 12:44 AM
不管動機爲何，根據  《哥林多前書  11：5-6》   婦女剃髮就是一種羞恥

King James Version:
I Corinthians 11:5-6
5 But every women that prayeth or prophesieth with her head uncovered dishonoureth her head: for what is even all one as if she were shaven.
6 For if the woman be not covered, let her also be sworn: but if it be a shame for a woman to be shorn or shaven, let her be covered.

Commentary:
http://www.bible-researcher.com/headcoverings.html
Although in ancient times the customs of female dress varied, women of all cultures allowed their hair to grow long. Nowhere was short hair the custom for women. Short hair on a woman was a sign of grief or disgrace. Among Jews, Greeks, and Romans, adulteresses sometimes had their hair cropped as an extremely humiliating punishment for their crime. Among the Jews this was done as someone recited the words, “because thou hast departed from the manner of the daughters of Israel, who go with their head covered … therefore that has befallen thee which thou hast chosen.” (6) Sometimes a Greek woman would cut her hair short as a sign of mourning, after the death of a family member. (7) A famous example of this is in the tragic story of Electra, who, after her father was murdered, cropped her hair short in token of her grief. Ancient depictions of Electra show her with her hair cut almost as short as a man’s. In the legend, Electra kept her hair short for years because she was determined to remain in mourning until her brother had avenged her father’s death, but this goes beyond the common custom. Also, there was a religious custom among the Greeks in which people (both male and female) would on certain occasions cut off a lock of hair and offer it to a deity. But there is no reason to think that in the case of women this votive offering involved any general shortening of the hair. (8)

这些经文从历史背景来看才是有道理的。怎么诠释不是你说了算的。

再说周玉清哀悼民主之死，落发也没有不妥吧。

若你真要那么hardcore遵守每一个细节的话，那么基督教女生是不是要戴tudung来cover她们的头?

不管周玉清有没有剃头发，她反抗的那种肮脏金钱政治都是错的、龌龊的。不要转移问题焦点，转移问题焦点可耻。

110_01

JowY 发表于 18-5-2013 10:42 AM
King James Version:
I Corinthians 11:5-6
5 But every women that prayeth or prophesieth with her  ...

本來就應該戴  tudung 的，爲什麽她們不戴？

好和坏

林冠英是天主教徒？

《文治征塵》

好和坏 发表于 18-5-2013 01:42 PM
林冠英是天主教徒？

是,林首長是天主教徒.

忧郁佬一佻

天呐。。怪不得行动党被传是西洋教的。。。

cikmekyee

只有诫命才不能改，只有诫命才一定要遵守。
哥前11章5-6节不是诫命！